The first time I put this book in a teenager's hands, she looked at the cover and asked a fair question: "Is this going to tell me to smile more?" I spent 28 years as a middle school counselor in Hilo, and I have heard every version of that suspicion. Kids can smell condescension through a closed door. So here is the honest answer, and it takes more than a paragraph to give it.
How to Win Friends and Influence People for Teen Girls is the teen edition of the Dale Carnegie classic, written by Donna Dale Carnegie and published by Simon & Schuster in a 2020 reissue. The paperback runs 208 pages and measures 5.5 by 0.5 by 8.38 inches, so it slides into a backpack side pocket without a fight. The listing shows a reading age of 10 to 14 and a grade level of 7 to 9. That range is close to right, a little young at the bottom and a little narrow at the top, and I will say why further down.
The Quick Verdict
One of the few social skills books a teenager will actually finish. The advice is plain, the tone is not preachy, and 208 pages is short enough that it never feels like homework. It cannot do the work for a kid who is in real trouble, and it should not be asked to.
Amazon Check Today's Price →The One I Hand Over Before the School Year Turns Hard
208 pages, plain advice, no lectures attached. Read the sample pages yourself first, the way I do, then leave it somewhere she will find it.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →How I've Used It With a Real Teenager
I read every book before I hand it to a kid. That rule has never once let me down, and it has saved me from recommending some confident nonsense over the years. I finished this one over two evenings in a chair on my lanai, which tells you something already, because I abandon roughly a third of the youth books that cross my table. Then I gave it to my grandson Kai, who is 15, a sophomore, plays volleyball, and would rather be on his phone than reading. I did not make a speech about it. I set it on the arm of the couch and said the true thing, which was that a counselor I trained with swore by it. He picked it up that night.
Kai read it in five sittings over about two weeks, which for him is a genuine result. What surprised me was not that he finished it. It was that he brought it up on his own, twice, without me asking. Once it was about a kid on his volleyball team who had gone quiet on him, and how he had been handling it badly. Once it was about a group chat that had turned ugly and whether saying nothing made him part of it. He did not quote the book at me. He just had language for something he had been feeling without a name for it, and at fifteen, language is most of the work.
The book circle was the harder test. I run a small Saturday morning group at my local public library, usually six to eight kids between 13 and 18, and they are a tough room for anything that smells like self-improvement. Two of them rolled their eyes at the title. Then a sixteen-year-old who barely talks in that room said she had already read it, and that the part about arguing had changed how she handled her mother. That set off forty minutes of argument, which is a fine outcome for a book about arguing. Roughly half the circle finished it. That is a normal completion rate for anything we read.
What Is Actually Between the Covers
The spine of the original is still here. Listening instead of waiting your turn to talk. Disagreeing without turning it into a contest. Remembering a person's name. Admitting you were wrong before someone makes you. What changed is the packaging, and the packaging matters more than adults usually admit. The tone is direct without turning into a lecture, and the situations are the ones that actually sting at that age: a friend who goes cold, a lunch table you are not sure you are welcome at, a group chat where everyone is watching and nobody is saying anything. Kai's generation would call the 1936 original a book for their grandparents. This one does not read that way.
The physical book is modest, and that is a point in its favor. 208 pages. Half an inch thick. It weighs nothing in a backpack, and the listed item weight of 2.31 pounds is plainly a shipping weight rather than the book itself. There are no charts, no fill-in exercises, no QR codes pointing at a website that will be dead in two years. You read it or you do not. That simplicity is the reason it gets finished, and it is also the main limitation, which I will get to.
One practical note on editions. The copy in front of me is the 2020 Simon & Schuster reissue, and it reads as though it was written for kids who have grown up with a group chat in their pocket. This teen edition has been through more than one printing over the years, so if you are buying a used copy, check which one you are getting. The principles do not change. The framing does, and the framing is the part a teenager notices.
What Sticks After a Few Months
Months out, I can tell you what survived and what did not. What survived, for Kai, was the listening. He is not a naturally patient kid, and I have watched him lately let a conversation finish before he jumps in, which is not a thing I taught him. What did not survive was any enthusiasm for rereading it. He read it once, took what he needed, and moved on. I think that is exactly what a book like this should produce. The books teenagers return to for years are usually novels. A book that hands them four or five tools in one pass has done its job.
Among the book circle kids the split was just as clear. The ones who got something were the ones who read it while something specific was still stinging: a friendship that had gone quiet, a first real fight with a parent, a tryout they were dreading. The ones who read it on a calm week enjoyed it and forgot it by the next meeting. That is not a flaw in the book so much as a fact about reading at that age. Timing does more for comprehension than any recommendation I could write.
The teenagers who got the most from it were not the ones who needed it most. They were the ones who read it while something was still stinging.
One more observation, because I think it matters. The kids did not talk about it as a book. They talked about it as something a person had told them. Donna Dale Carnegie writes in a voice that sounds like an adult taking a teenager seriously rather than an adult performing enthusiasm, and the kids took it in as advice from a person instead of a lesson from a curriculum. That is the difference between a book that gets passed around a lunch table and one that gets buried under a math folder in October.
I should say something about the adult side, since I have now recommended this to more parents than teenagers. What adults take from it is a reminder of how much of a teenager's coldness is actually fear. The book says that plainly, in a way that does not excuse the behavior but explains it, and an explanation is usually what a frustrated parent is missing. Two mothers in my extended family borrowed it after their daughters finished and both said the same thing, that they wished someone had handed it to them at fourteen. That is not a reason to buy it. It is a reason to read the first chapter before you pass it on.
Where It Falls Short
Now the honest part, because a review without it is an advertisement. This is still a book, and a book cannot role-play with you. It cannot watch you try a new approach on a real friend and tell you where it went sideways. It cannot notice that the kid reading it is being excluded at school every day, which is a situation that needs an adult in the room and probably a counselor, not a paperback. I have referred families for help over things no book was going to touch. If your teenager is in genuine distress, buy the book and also make the call. The book is a nudge. It is a good nudge. It is not a fix.
The examples skew young, too. A 16 or 17-year-old will find some of the situations a step behind where they actually live, and more than one kid in my circle said exactly that. Boys found parts of it a step removed, since it is written with girls in mind, and while the principles translate fine, the framing asks a boy to do some translation work on his own. And there is no companion workbook, no prompts to write into, nothing to fill out. If your teenager is the type who needs to write in order to think, this book alone will not carry them. Plan on talking about it. That part is on you.
How to Hand It Over Without Ruining It
The single most common way this book fails is that an adult turns it into an assignment. I have watched it happen. A well-meaning parent reads a review, orders it, hands it over with a sentence about how it will help with the friend situation, and the teenager puts it on a shelf out of principle. The fix is boring and it works. Say less. Leave it somewhere visible and say nothing at all, or say only that you read it and thought it was interesting. Let curiosity do the work, because a teenager's curiosity is strong and their resistance to being managed is stronger.
The second way it fails is timing. Give it during a calm stretch and it lands as a school supply. Give it in the middle of a real mess and it lands as a life raft. You cannot manufacture the second situation and you should not try. What you can do is keep a copy around so that when the mess arrives, the book is already there and does not need to be produced as an answer. A book already on the shelf gets picked up. A book that appears the week after a crisis gets resisted. Donna Dale Carnegie's tone does a lot of the work here, but proximity does the rest.
What I Liked
- Short enough to actually finish: 208 pages, half an inch thick
- Plain, direct tone that never reads like a lecture
- Situations match what teenagers deal with, friendship and group chats included
- Leaves a teenager with language for things they were already feeling
- Affordable enough to hand over without ceremony
Where It Falls Short
- Examples skew toward the younger end of the listed 10 to 14 reading age
- Written for girls, so boys have to translate some of the framing
- No exercises, prompts or workbook pages to work through
- A book alone will not help a teenager in real distress
- Nothing here for a kid who needs to write in order to think
Who This Is For
This is for the parent, grandparent, teacher or mentor of a girl roughly 11 to 16 who is starting to notice that friendships have rules nobody explains out loud. Hand it over without a speech. Leave it on a couch or a car seat or the kitchen counter and go do something else. Read the first thirty pages yourself so you can answer a question if one comes, because one probably will. It is also for a teenager buying it herself, which happens more than adults assume, since the title promises something specific and the title is not lying. Donna Dale Carnegie is aiming at a real gap here and she hits it.
Who Should Skip It
Skip it if you want a workbook, a discussion guide, or something to assign as homework. Skip it if the teenager in question is in real social trouble at school, because this is a nudge and not a rescue, and treating it as a rescue wastes months you do not get back. Skip it if you plan to quiz her on it afterward, since nothing kills a book faster than a comprehension check. And skip it if you need something that speaks equally to boys and girls from the first page. It does not, and Donna Dale Carnegie was never trying to.
Leave It on the Couch and Say Nothing
208 pages. No workbook, no lectures, nothing to fill in. The teenagers who finish it are the ones who were not told to. Check today's price and read the first few pages before you hand it over.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →