The book sat on my kitchen counter for eleven days before anyone touched it. I put it there on purpose. After twenty-eight years as a middle school counselor, I learned early that handing a teenager a book and saying 'you should read this' is the fastest way to guarantee it stays closed. So I said nothing. I set it next to the bowl of oranges, right where Kai passes on his way to the fridge, and I waited.
Kai is fifteen, a sophomore, and a volleyball player who would rather hold his phone than a paperback. He is not in trouble and he is not failing anything. He had simply gone quiet the way I have watched a hundred kids go quiet. Answers trimmed to 'fine' and 'later'. Eyes on a screen. Conversation with adults treated as a chore to be survived. I had already read How to Win Friends and Influence People for Teen Girls by Donna Dale Carnegie myself, and what I wanted to know was whether he would open it without being assigned.
On the twelfth morning the book was gone from the counter. It turned up on the arm of the couch with a grocery receipt stuck in it as a bookmark. He did not mention it. Two nights later I looked over and he was reading under the lamp with his phone face down on the side table. The phone face down is the part I keep coming back to. In our house that is a deliberate act.
Then, about two weeks in, he asked me a question at dinner that had nothing to do with the book. He wanted to know how you start a conversation with somebody you do not know yet. Not in theory. There was a transfer student on the volleyball team, a quiet kid, and Kai had spent a week sitting near him without saying a word to him. We talked about it for ten minutes. Ten minutes does not sound like much until you have been getting 'fine' for four months.
He asked how to start a conversation with the new kid on the team. That was the entire return on the book, and it was enough for me.
The book he picked up without being told to
208 pages, published by Simon & Schuster. Reading age listed as 10 to 14, grade level 7 to 9. It sat on my counter for eleven days and then it disappeared into his room.
Amazon See it on Amazon →I also handed it to the book circle kids, the six to eight teenagers who meet at the library on Saturday mornings. That group spans thirteen to eighteen and they do not agree about much. Two of them finished it and wanted to argue about whether being nice is the same thing as being fake. That argument lasted most of an hour and nobody looked at a phone. A third kid read forty pages and stopped, which is honest information too. No book lands with every reader.
For what it is worth on the practical side, the edition I bought is the 2020 reissue from Simon & Schuster. It runs 208 pages and measures about five and a half by eight and a third inches, so it slides into a backpack alongside a load that is already full of textbooks. Donna Dale Carnegie writes to the reader directly rather than at her, which is why I think teenagers give it a chance. It reads like advice from somebody who assumes you are smart.
Now the honest part. A book is a nudge, not a repair. If your teenager is struggling with something serious, anxiety, a bullying situation, a real depression, this paperback is not the answer and I would never sell it to you as one. It also will not fix a kid who has decided that reading is not for him. Kai came to it because it was sitting there and nobody pushed. Push it and you may get the opposite. And the title says teen girls while my test reader is a boy, which tells you something useful: the material is not gendered in any way that got in his way.
Where it fits best is the teenager who is not in crisis but has quietly stopped talking. The one who eats dinner with the family and says four words. The one who wants friends and does not know how to begin. It also works well as a read-along, where you read it and your kid reads it and neither of you makes it a big production. That is how the book circle used it and it is how I would suggest a family use it.
What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table
I would tell you to skip the lecture. Do not hand this book over with a speech attached, because the speech is what makes it homework. Leave it somewhere visible and let curiosity do the work. I would tell you to read it yourself first, both because you should know what your kid is reading and because you will find a thing or two in it that you could use at work on Monday. I would tell you that Donna Dale Carnegie is not writing for parents, she is writing for the kid, and that is exactly why it works.
I would tell you not to measure the result in conversations you started. Measure it in the smaller signs: the phone face down, the question asked, the name at dinner that you have not heard before. And I would tell you that one book will not raise your teenager. It might open a door that was already there. That is a modest thing to hope for, and it is also how most real change starts. Twenty-eight years in a middle school taught me that much.
Leave it on the counter and see what happens
How to Win Friends and Influence People for Teen Girls by Donna Dale Carnegie. 208 pages, Simon & Schuster, reading age listed as 10 to 14.
Amazon See it on Amazon →