Most reviews of this book are written by someone who liked it a great deal and wants you to like it too. This one comes from someone who read it, handed it to eight teenagers, and then watched what actually happened over six weeks. How to Win Friends and Influence People for Teen Girls has real strengths and three specific weaknesses that the product page never mentions. You should know both before you put it in front of a girl you care about, because a book handed over at the wrong age does more harm than a book never handed over at all.

I am Grace Nakamura. I spent 28 years as a middle school counselor in public schools, and I am retired now, living in Hilo, Hawaii, where I run a small Saturday morning book circle at the public library. My grandson Kai is 15 and serves as my test reader whether he agrees to or not. This book was written by Donna Dale Carnegie and published by Simon & Schuster in August 2020 as a reissue. That word, reissue, is doing more work than it looks like it is doing, and I will come back to it. First, what you are actually buying.

The Quick Verdict

★★★★☆ 7.8/10

A short, kind, genuinely readable social skills book that lands best with girls aged 11 to 14. It is not a workbook, it will not solve a friendship crisis, and it reads younger than the cover suggests.

Check Today's Price →

The right book at the right age beats ten books at the wrong one

208 pages, short chapters, and a voice that never lectures. For a girl in the 11 to 14 range who has started noticing the social weather around her, this is the one I hand over first.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

What This Book Actually Is, and What It Is Not

It is not the 1936 book, and it does not pretend to be. Donna Dale Carnegie takes the same core ideas, listen more than you talk, remember a person's name, admit your own mistakes quickly, try to see the other side of an argument, and translates them for a reader whose whole social world fits inside a lunch table and a group chat. The ideas are old. The situations are not.

Physically it is an ordinary paperback. 208 pages, roughly 5.5 by 8.38 inches, light enough to disappear into a school bag and unremarkable enough that a girl will carry it without feeling marked. The publisher lists a grade level of 7 through 9 and a reading age of 10 to 14 years based on customer feedback. Those two numbers matter more than any review you will read, mine included, because they tell you who the book was built for.

What it is not is a workbook. There is nothing to fill in, no exercise pages, no prompt at the end of each section asking the reader to reflect. A girl reads it or she does not, and that means the entire thing rests on whether the voice on the page pulls her forward. For most of the girls I handed it to, it did. For the ones it did not, no amount of my enthusiasm was going to change that.

The book held open flat on a kitchen table with a teenager's hands resting on the pages beside a glass of water

How I Tested It: One Grandson, One Book Circle, Six Weeks

My grandson Kai is 15 and a high school sophomore. He plays volleyball, he would rather be on his phone than reading almost anything, and he treats a book the way he treats a vegetable on his plate, which is to say he evaluates it before touching it. He is also a boy, so I gave him this one as a test of the writing rather than the advice. He finished it in four sittings. That surprised me enough that I asked him why, and he said the ideas about arguing would work on his coach. That is the highest compliment a 15 year old boy gives a book.

The book circle kids were a harder room. I usually have six to eight of them on a Saturday, aged 13 to 18, and they are honest in the way only teenagers in a library meeting room can be. The 16 and up crowd looked at the title and mentally left. I understand it. A book that puts teen girls on the cover is telling a 17 year old something about who it thinks she is, and she may not agree. The ones who finished and wanted to talk were almost all 13 and 14.

Six weeks after I handed it out, I asked what they remembered. Not what they learned, what they remembered, because the second question gets a polite answer and the first one gets the truth. Two girls independently brought up the idea of letting the other person finish talking before you decide what you think of what they said. One said she had tried it on her mother and the conversation had gone better than usual. That is the whole argument for this book in one small report from a real kitchen.

Six weeks later, what stuck was not a rule from a page. It was a girl letting her mother finish a sentence before answering.

What Nobody Tells You Before You Buy It

It reads younger than the cover suggests. If you look at the title and the packaging, you will assume high school, and you would be half right. The girls who responded best were 11 to 14. When I handed it to a 16 year old, she read a few pages, set it down politely, and told me she already knew all of this. She was not being difficult. She had simply moved past the point where a plain explanation of people is useful to her, and the book had nothing left to offer someone who had already worked it out.

It is a reissue, and if you read the customer reviews you will find a small group calling it dated. They are not wrong, exactly. A few of the examples and the general cheerfulness of the tone feel like they were written by an adult who means well, because they were. Nothing in it reads like it came from a 14 year old. That is the trade for the clarity, and most readers will take that trade happily, but you should expect it going in so you are not surprised halfway through.

The shipped weight is listed at 2.31 pounds, which is heavier than a paperback this size has any business being. I assume that figure covers the packaging. I bring it up only because it is the kind of number people read meaning into, and it tells you nothing at all about what the book is like to hold or to read.

There are no built-in discussion questions that I could find, and I looked properly. For a book that a parent buys specifically hoping to start a conversation, that is a real gap. I ended up writing three questions of my own on an index card and tucking it inside the front cover, and the girls used them without being asked twice. A reading guide would have saved me twenty minutes and would make this book considerably more useful to the adults who buy it.

Where the Book Genuinely Earns Its Place

The tone is the thing. It never scolds. It keeps returning to the idea that most people are not thinking about you nearly as much as you assume they are, which is the single most useful sentence you can put in front of a 13 year old girl. It also comes back, in several different ways, to the fact that admitting a mistake first takes the wind out of an argument before the argument has a chance to fill its sails. I have watched that idea land with teenagers for three decades, and it lands here too, mostly because the book does not oversell it.

What Donna Dale Carnegie does well is keep the chapters short. Short chapters are not a small thing. A girl who has quietly decided she is bad at reading will finish a short chapter and feel differently about herself for the rest of the day. I have watched a good book lose a kid on page eleven because the first chapter ran twenty pages. This one does not make that mistake, and for a reluctant reader that is most of the battle.

It is also practical in a way that social skills books often are not. It gives a girl language. Not scripts to memorize and recite back, because a memorized line sounds memorized and everyone can hear it. Phrasing she can bend to fit the moment. Several of the book circle kids said some version of this, that they knew what to say now in a situation where previously they had only known they wanted to leave.

Teenagers sitting in a loose circle on folding chairs in a library meeting room with books on their laps

The Parts That Fell Flat

It is a book about being likable, and being likable is not the same thing as being safe. If a girl is dealing with real hostility, an exclusion campaign, or a group that has decided to turn on her, this book will gently suggest she look at her own approach. That is useful advice for the ordinary friction of growing up. It is close to useless against genuine cruelty, and I want to say that plainly, because a parent in a panic will buy whatever is on the nearest shelf and expect it to do something it cannot do.

The online material is thinner than the in-person material. The book knows how to describe a conversation across a lunch table. A girl's social life happens in a group chat at eleven at night, and the advice does not stretch quite that far. I wanted more there. So did the older kids in the circle, and they said so without much prompting.

And there is an earnestness to the whole thing that a certain kind of reader will feel as a wall. It is the voice of an adult who wants the best for you, which is exactly the voice a 15 year old is built to resist. That is not a flaw in the writing so much as a fact about teenagers. It is the reason I keep saying the age range matters more than the title on the front.

What I Liked

  • Short chapters a reluctant reader can actually finish
  • A kind tone that never turns into a lecture
  • Gives girls usable language for everyday conflict
  • Honest about the small daily things that fill a teenager's week
  • A paperback that travels well in a school bag

Where It Falls Short

  • Reads younger than the cover suggests
  • No built-in discussion questions for parents
  • Light on group chat and online conflict
  • Not built for real hostility or exclusion
  • Some examples feel dated to older teens

Who This Is For

A girl between 11 and 14 who has started to notice the social weather around her. That means she has begun to care what a particular group of people thinks of her and has not yet finished deciding who she is. That is the sweet spot, and it is narrow. She will read it in about a week, she will deny that it helped, and six weeks later you will hear her use something from it in the car and you will have the good sense not to say anything.

It is also for the adult who wants a low-stakes way in. A grandmother, an aunt, a teacher, a youth leader, a neighbor who has watched a kid grow up. You do not have to discuss it. You hand it over, you wait, and eventually a question arrives on its own. My advice is to answer the question and then stop talking, which is the hardest advice in this entire review for me to follow and I have had 28 years of practice.

Who Should Skip It

Girls 16 and older, mostly. By that age a young woman has usually worked out her own operating theory of people, even if it is a rough one, and a book that explains friendship in plain language can feel like being talked down to by someone who has never met her friends. If she is 16 and genuinely curious, hand her the original instead. She can handle it, and she will respect you for trusting her with the adult version.

Skip it if you are looking for a solution to something serious. If a girl is being bullied, isolated, or struggling in a way that has moved past ordinary friendship trouble, a paperback is not the tool and this paperback is not the paperback. That is a conversation with a counselor and possibly with a school. A book is a nudge. It is not a fix, and anyone who tells you a book will fix it is selling something you should not buy.

What I will say, after 28 years of watching teenagers sort themselves out and one more Saturday morning with a book circle, is that this is a good nudge. It says true things in a warm voice at the right length for a girl who is still deciding what kind of person she wants to be. If she is 13, the odds are decent that she finishes it. If she is 16, the odds are not, and that is nobody's fault. Donna Dale Carnegie wrote it for the younger one, and the younger one is who should get it.

If she is 13, she will finish it. If she is 16, she probably will not.

That is the honest line after six weeks of watching. Buy it for the girl who is still forming her social instincts, not the one who has already formed them and is tired of hearing about them.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →