Six months ago I set a book on the coffee table in my living room and said absolutely nothing about it. That is the only reliable way to get a fifteen-year-old to read something you chose. Kai is a high school sophomore, he plays volleyball, and if he has a free hour he will spend it on his phone. I spent twenty-eight years as a middle school counselor before I retired, and in that time I watched a great many well-meaning adults press a book into a teenager's hands and then watch it die on a nightstand by Thursday.

You Are Awesome by Matthew Syed is one of the few that did not die there. It runs 160 pages, it is illustrated throughout, and a good chunk of it asks the reader to write in the book rather than nod along. I read it myself first, then handed it to Kai, then brought it to the Saturday morning book circle I run at the public library here in Hilo. Half a year later I can tell you what it actually does for a kid, what it does not do, and which teenagers will never open it no matter how kindly you hand it over.

The Quick Verdict

★★★★½ 8.6/10

Short, illustrated, and built around prompts a kid has to write in. Best for ages 11 to 15 who will actually pick up a pencil. Not for the teenager who finds encouragement embarrassing.

Check Today's Price →

If your kid has already decided they are bad at something, start here

160 pages, illustrated, and it asks for a pencil. Short enough that a teenager who does not read might still finish it.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

How I've Used It

My method is not scientific and I have never pretended it is. I read the book in two evenings on my own, with a pencil, filling in the prompts the way a kid would. Then I left it on the coffee table and said nothing. Kai picked it up on a Sunday afternoon while his phone was charging in the kitchen, which is the closest thing to a fair test I can arrange. He read the first thirty pages standing up.

The book circle was the harder test. We meet Saturday mornings at the library, usually six to eight kids between thirteen and eighteen, and I brought eight copies and told them they could take one or leave one. Four went home. Of those four, two brought the book back the following week with pages filled in, one read about half and stopped, and one never mentioned it again. I did not chase any of them. A book you are forced to finish teaches a kid that reading is a chore, and I have seen enough of that for one career.

What I watched for was not whether they finished. It was what they brought up afterward, unprompted, in the following weeks. That is the only measure that has ever meant anything to me. A kid who quotes a book back at you in an argument got something from it. A kid who says it was fine and changes the subject did not.

A teenager's hand writing an answer on the open pages of a workbook-style book

What's Actually Inside the 160 Pages

The physical book is modest. It measures 6.25 by 8.75 inches, weighs about 1.1 pounds, and runs 160 pages in an illustrated edition from Sourcebooks Explore, published in July 2019. That trim size matters more than it sounds like it should. It fits in a backpack, it does not look like a textbook, and a kid can hold it in one hand. I have watched teenagers refuse books purely on the grounds that they looked like homework.

I measured the sections because I wanted to know whether a kid with a short attention span could get a win. A typical section runs two to four pages, most of that illustration and white space, and then there is a prompt. I timed myself reading one the way a kid would, pencil in hand, writing the answers instead of skipping them. Four minutes. That is a length a fifteen-year-old will tolerate on a Tuesday night, and short enough that stopping in the middle of a section feels silly, which is the whole trick. A chapter book asks for a commitment before it pays anything back. This one pays in the first five minutes and then asks for another five.

The publisher lists a reading age of 9 to 12 and a grade level of 4 to 6. I would treat that as a floor, not a ceiling. The vocabulary is easy, which is the point, but the ideas land harder with kids who have already been disappointed by something. A ninth grader who tried a thing and quit has more use for this book than a fourth grader who has not been tested yet. When I handed it to a fifteen-year-old, I was not worried it would be beneath him. I was worried he would decide it was, and that is a different problem.

Structurally it is short sections rather than long chapters. Matthew Syed builds each one around a single idea, illustrates it with a story, and then hands the reader a prompt. Some prompts are questions. Some are lists. Some ask the reader to write down a time they did something badly and then got better at it. The book expects a pencil. It is not the kind of thing you read on a phone, and I count that as a feature rather than a flaw.

What Got Through to Kai

The idea that stuck with him was the one about practice and how skill actually accumulates. He had been carrying around a quiet belief that some kids are simply built to be good at volleyball and he was not one of them. The book does not argue with that belief head-on. It walks the reader through examples of people who were unremarkable at something and got better anyway, then asks the reader to find their own example. Kai wrote about his serve.

There was a Thursday night scrimmage in late March where he missed four serves in a row and the other team stopped pretending to return them. He was quiet in the car and I did not fill the silence, which took effort. About a mile from home he said the thing I had been waiting for, which was that he did not understand why his body would not do what he could clearly picture. That is a practice question, not a confidence question. He got there himself. If I had said it, it would have been a lecture. Because a book had said it three weeks earlier, it was his own thought.

That was in March. His serve was the weakest part of his game and he knew it. What changed was not his attitude, and I want to be plain about that, because I have read too many reviews of books like this that promise a transformation. What changed was that he stopped treating the serve as evidence of a fixed limit and started treating it as a thing he had not practiced enough. He stayed after practice twice a week for about a month. He is not a great server now. He is a noticeably better one, and he knows exactly why, and that knowledge is worth more to me than the serve.

The second thing that got through was smaller. There is a section on how people talk to themselves, and Kai mentioned it once at dinner, almost in passing, that he had noticed he was calling himself an idiot after mistakes in a way he would never talk to a teammate. He did not make a project out of it. He just noticed. That is what a book can do, and honestly it is most of what a book can do.

What the Book Circle Did With It

The four kids who took copies home split cleanly, and the split was informative. The two who filled in pages were the two who already had some appetite for self-improvement. They would have read something this spring. The book gave them a better something than they would have found on their own. The one who read half and stopped told me it felt like being coached, and she already has three coaches in her life between school and sports and did not want a fourth.

The one who never mentioned it again is the kid I think about most. Thirteen years old, plenty capable, allergic to anything that resembles a pep talk. I do not think the book failed her. I think handing a book about believing in yourself to a kid who finds that idea embarrassing is like handing a vegetarian a steak. Wrong tool, wrong reader, nobody's fault.

I tried a different approach the following Saturday. Instead of asking what they thought of the book, I asked them to name one thing they had quit in the last year and one reason they quit, and I wrote the reasons on the whiteboard without attaching any names. Eight reasons went up. Six were some version of not being good at it. Nobody had to defend anything because nothing had a name next to it. We spent the rest of the hour arguing with the whiteboard instead of with each other. That is the most useful thing a book like this does. It gives a group a way to talk about something they would not otherwise bring up.

What the group discussion did produce was a better conversation than I expected, and it came out of the weakest part of the book. One of the older kids pointed out that the examples lean heavily toward athletes and performers, and that not every teenager wants to be either. That turned into a twenty-minute argument about whether you can be good at something nobody claps for. It was the best twenty minutes of the month, and it started because a book by Matthew Syed was imperfect enough to push back against.

A small group of teenagers seated around a library table with books and notebooks open

Where It Falls Short

The tone is relentlessly encouraging, and for some kids that is a wall rather than a door. A sixteen-year-old who has had a hard year will sometimes read three pages of enthusiasm and decide the author has never met anyone like them. There is no section for the kid whose problem is not self-belief but a genuinely difficult situation at home. The book is not built for that and does not pretend to be.

The write-in format has a practical cost. Once a kid fills in the prompts, the book is theirs and cannot be handed down or resold. If you are buying for a classroom, that means one copy per student, and you should know that going in rather than discovering it in September.

I asked a former colleague who still runs a middle school counseling office whether she would use it in groups. Her answer was careful and I will pass it along as she gave it. She said she would use it with the kids who come to her already asking questions, and she would not hand it to a kid who was sent to her. That distinction has held up in everything I have watched since. The book works when the reader arrived with some curiosity. It does very little when it is prescribed.

The reading age label on the listing is the other snag. Nine to twelve is accurate for the reading level and optimistic for the interest level. A twelve-year-old will get through it. A fifteen-year-old will get through it faster and complain that it looks like a book for middle schoolers, and then read it anyway when nobody is watching. I have seen that exact sequence twice now.

What I Liked

  • Short sections and writing prompts keep kids who do not read much moving
  • 160 pages at 6.25 by 8.75 inches fits in a backpack and does not look like homework
  • Illustrated throughout, so it reads as a workbook rather than a lecture
  • The practice framing gives a kid something to do rather than something to feel
  • A 4.7 average across 4,274 ratings suggests it lands with a lot of readers

Where It Falls Short

  • The write-in pages make it a single-reader book that cannot be passed down
  • The tone is upbeat enough that some older teens will bounce off it
  • Athlete and performer examples dominate
  • The 9 to 12 reading age label undersells who it is actually useful for
  • Not built for a kid dealing with something serious at home
He is not a great server now. He is a noticeably better one, and he knows exactly why, and that knowledge is worth more to me than the serve.

Who This Is For

This is for the kid who has decided they are bad at something and stopped. Not bad in a dramatic way. Bad in the ordinary way, the way most of us are bad at most things at thirteen. If you have a teenager who quietly avoids a subject or a sport because they have already decided how it ends, this book gives them a different explanation for why they are where they are. It is short enough that they might actually finish it, and the prompts mean they have to put something of themselves on the page rather than skim.

It is also for the adult who wants to say something helpful and keeps saying the wrong thing. Several parents in my book circle read it after their kid did, and the ones who got the most from it used it to start a conversation rather than to end one.

Who Should Skip It

Skip it if your kid is already a steady reader with a full shelf and a taste for something with more teeth. There are longer, harder books on the same idea and this one will feel like a warm-up. Skip it if the teenager in question is carrying something heavy, because cheerful practice advice is not what that kid needs and reaching for it can read as dismissive.

And skip it if you are buying a fix rather than a nudge. Matthew Syed wrote a book. It is a good one, and it is still a book. It will not change a kid's year. It might give them one useful sentence to say to themselves in a bad moment, and if that is what you are hoping for, it earns its shelf space.

A book is a nudge, not a fix. This one is a good nudge.

Read it yourself first, then leave it where they will find it. That order matters more than which book you pick.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →