Your teenager will read one of these books and not the other, and that single fact decides the whole comparison. Do Hard Things, by Alex and Brett Harris, was written by two nineteen-year-olds who believed their generation had been handed a pathetically low bar. Grit, by Angela Duckworth, was written by a psychologist who spent a career measuring why some people keep going when the work stops being fun. One book talks directly to your kid. The other one explains your kid to you. Which one goes on the nightstand depends on whether you need a push or a map.
I spent 28 years as a middle school counselor in public schools, and I now run a Saturday morning book circle at the public library in Hilo, usually six to eight kids between 13 and 18. I read every book myself before I hand it out, then I watch what happens. Whether a kid finishes it, and what they bring up three weeks later, tells me more than any endorsement on a back cover. That is the only credential I am offering here, and it has been enough to separate these two books pretty cleanly.
| Do Hard Things | Grit | |
|---|---|---|
| Voice | Two teenagers writing to their peers, first person, with jokes that land | A research psychologist writing to adults, with teen readers in mind but not in the room |
| Evidence base | Stories from the authors' own campaign and letters from teenage readers | Decades of studies, including West Point cadets, spelling bee finalists and sales data |
| Reading level | Aimed at readers 11 to 14 and up, comfortable at a seventh to ninth grade level | Written for adults; most teens do better with a parent or teacher reading alongside |
| What it asks of the reader | Ends every chapter with something concrete to do this week | Builds understanding, with less of a to-do list at the end of each chapter |
| Pace | 320 pages in short chapters a reluctant reader can finish | Denser arguments that reward a patient reader and slow a restless one |
| Staying power | Burns bright at 15 and can feel dated by 19, because the voice belongs to a teenager | Reads the same at 17 and at 40, because the frame is not tied to being young |
| Classroom use | Openly Christian, says so on page one, so you need to know your audience first | Secular throughout, easy to assign in a public school |
| Best for | A kid who needs a reason to try something hard this month | A kid who is already trying and needs to understand why it feels so heavy |
What Each Book Is Actually Arguing
Do Hard Things argues that adolescence as we currently practice it is a modern invention, and not a very good one. Alex and Brett Harris make the case that the teenage years got stretched into a holding pattern of school, sports and screens, and that the bar got lowered so far that clearing it means nothing. Their fix is not to relax and enjoy being young. It is to go find something hard, something that takes real effort and does not pay off immediately, and do that instead. The book sorts those challenges into rough categories: things outside your comfort zone, things that take longer than a weekend, things you cannot do alone, and things that go against what everyone around you is doing.
Grit argues something narrower and better evidenced. Duckworth defines grit as passion and perseverance for long term goals, then spends the book showing that it predicts outcomes at West Point, in the National Spelling Bee, in sales jobs and in classrooms, often better than raw talent does. She breaks grit into four things that can be grown: interest, practice, purpose and hope. Notice the shape of that list. It is a description of a disposition, not a set of assignments.
Put the two side by side and the difference is not quality. It is address. One book is a letter to a fifteen year old. The other is a briefing for the adult standing behind the fifteen year old. A lot of the arguing that happens in reviews of these books comes from people who wanted one of them to be the other.
Failure is the other quiet disagreement. Duckworth treats failure as data. Her chapters are full of people who were told no, went back, adjusted and kept at it, and the lesson is that the setback is information about the method, not a verdict on the person. Alex and Brett Harris treat it differently. For them a hard thing that goes badly is closer to evidence that you were aiming at something worth aiming at, which is a bracing message and a less useful one when a kid is already discouraged. A reader in a good place hears a challenge. A reader in a bad place hears an indictment. Worth knowing before you hand either book over.
Where Do Hard Things Wins
The first win is credibility, and it is not a small one. Every adult who has handed a teenager a book about working harder has run into the same wall: who are you, and why should I care. Alex and Brett Harris did not climb that wall. They walked around it by being the same age as the reader when they wrote it. Kai is 15, and the reason he kept going past chapter three is that the authors sounded like people he might actually know. That is a structural advantage no researcher can buy, no matter how good the research is.
The second win is that the book always ends a chapter by asking for something. Not a reflection question. An action. My book circle kids can tell you which chapters they have actually done something about, because those are the chapters they still bring up months later. And it is readable in the plain sense: 320 pages, aimed at readers 11 to 14 and up, laid out at a seventh to ninth grade level, in short chapters that do not require a study guide to get through. A book a kid finishes at 60 percent beats a better book they abandon at page 40.
Where Grit Wins
Grit wins on evidence, and it is not close. Duckworth is not trading in anecdotes or scripture. She is reporting decades of research, and when she makes a claim you can trace it back to a study. For a parent who has been told a hundred times that their kid just needs to try harder, that matters. It replaces a slogan with a mechanism. The four assets she names, interest, practice, purpose and hope, give you something to actually ask about at dinner. Where is the interest, and what would make this feel purposeful to you, rather than what are you doing with your life.
Grit also wins on staying power, and this is where the two books split permanently. Do Hard Things is written in a teenage voice, which is exactly why it works at 15 and exactly why it can feel dated at 19. Grit reads the same at 17 and at 40. I have handed it to a seventeen year old in the circle and to her mother in the same week, and both got something out of it. It also clears a practical hurdle that Do Hard Things does not: it is entirely secular, so a teacher can assign it in a public school without a conversation about religion first. Do Hard Things is openly Christian and says so on page one, which is fine in the right setting and a problem in the wrong one.
There is a cost to Grit that cuts in its favor and against it at the same time. It assumes a reader who can hold a long argument. Duckworth builds her cases across chapters and circles back to them, which is satisfying for an adult and slow going for a fourteen year old. I have had better luck giving it to older teens, or reading it alongside a kid a chapter at a time, than handing it over cold. Used that way it is the richer of the two books by a wide margin.
If Your Kid Needs a Push More Than a Lecture
Do Hard Things is the one my book circle actually finishes. 320 pages, short chapters, and a real challenge at the end of every single one. Hand it to a kid who is bored, not a kid who is already beaten down.
Amazon Check It Out on Amazon →Nine of the ten kids who started Do Hard Things finished it. In my book circle, that number is close to unheard of.
What I Have Watched in the Book Circle
The pattern repeats often enough that I have stopped being surprised by it. The kids who finish Do Hard Things are not my strongest readers. They are my most restless ones, the ones who are visibly bored by school and know it. The book gives that boredom somewhere to go. One boy read the chapter about doing things that do not pay off immediately, disappeared for two weeks, and came back having organized a Saturday cleanup at a beach park. He wanted to tell everyone about it. That is the book doing the thing it was built to do.
Grit produces a different reaction. The kids who finish it tend to want to talk, not do. They bring questions. One girl asked whether grit could be grown in a kid who had never really been allowed to fail at anything, and then answered her own question before I could, which is usually the sign that a book has landed. Grit makes a reader feel oriented. It does not make them feel summoned.
Kai is my test case for anything aimed at teenagers. He plays volleyball, he would rather be on his phone than reading, and he is honest with me in the blunt way that fifteen year old boys are honest with their grandmother. He finished Do Hard Things in about ten days, which for him is fast. He read Grit in pieces over a month, and only after I told him it explained why his club coach is the way he is. Both books got read. Only one got read voluntarily. Which one your kid picks up cold is worth knowing before you buy.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy Do Hard Things for a kid who is drifting, bored, or convinced that nothing they do at 15 counts. Buy it for the kid who says there is nothing to do in this town. Buy it for a youth group, a scout troop, or a family that already shares the faith it is written from. Buy it if you want a book that ends with the reader doing something this month rather than thinking about something. It is aimed at readers 11 to 14 and up, and it is the one I would put in the hands of a reluctant reader before any other title in this category.
Buy Grit for the kid who is already trying and cannot figure out why it feels so heavy. Buy it for the honor student who is terrified of losing, for the athlete in a slump, for the kid who quit three things and wants to understand that pattern. Buy it for yourself if you are the one who has to keep saying the encouraging thing and could use a better reason to believe it. Buy it if you teach in a public school and need something you can assign without a permission slip.
If you can only buy one and the kid is 13 to 16, buy Do Hard Things. If the kid is 17 or older, or already motivated, buy Grit. If you are buying for a classroom, buy Grit. If you are buying for a church group, buy Do Hard Things. That is the shortest version of my answer, and I have given it to a lot of parents in the hallway outside my old office.
The One Thing Neither Book Does
Neither book will make your kid gritty. I want to be plain about that, because covers promise more than a book can deliver. A book is a nudge. It gives a kid language for something they were already half feeling, and sometimes that language is enough to tip a decision. But a kid who has never been allowed to fail, who has had every hard thing smoothed out of their path by an adult who loves them, will not be rescued by 320 pages. The book can only name the problem. Somebody in the room has to stop smoothing.
I also will not tell you either book will change a grade, a season, or an admission letter. I have watched both books help kids and I have watched both sit on a nightstand with a bookmark stuck at page nine. If you want my honest split: buy Do Hard Things to start something, buy Grit to understand something. Buy whichever one matches the kid in front of you, and then, and this is the part that matters, ask them about it. The book is the excuse for the conversation. The conversation is the thing that works.
Start With the One Your Kid Will Actually Finish
Do Hard Things, by Alex and Brett Harris. 320 pages, short chapters, and something to do at the end of every one. It is the book my book circle finishes.
Amazon Check It Out on Amazon →